2016 X5 50i vs. 2016 X5 M

[Payton3485]

I was all set to purchase the X5 50i M Sport loaded with options but then came across the X5M. I'm new to the forum but have been reading posts in both areas. I'm looking for opinions contrasting both models and whether in your opinion the cost difference is worth it or not. I'm a huge fan of the M series as I own and have owned several M3's in the past. How good of a discount are you guys getting on the X5M currently? I'm looking to finance vs. lease either one. All input is appreciated. Thanks in advance!

[UrbanExtant]

There's a thread that's already discussed much of what you are asking. Here's a link to it.

http://f15.bimmerpost.com/forums/sho...1229213&page=2

[trev230]

I owned a 2011 X5 50i LOADED. It was time for a new vehicle. I test drove a 2016 X5 50i loaded out. Then I test drove the M and there wasn't a decision to be had anymore

The M is in a class of it's own FAR away from the 50i, which is a damn nice vehicle with a lot of power.

I typically purchase our vehicles. Leasing the M made more sense, especially with my short history of keeping vehicles these days. If you can get the right deal with the right numbers the lease is the way to go (if that's what you are after). Honestly, I like the M so much I would buy it outright in a heartbeat if I had too

[PatrickC23]

If you've had an M, I cant imagine you would dislike it, unless you are an old school M guy looking for a manual tranny and a more old school feel like the e30 or e46. I cannot comment on either X5s as I have never had one, but I never even considered the regular X5 as I knew the X5M would satisfy what I wanted in a vehicle.

My wife's X5M is on order, and for us, there is a huge difference in appearance alone when you see them side by side (maybe not so much the M-Sport pack) but you also know whats underneath the hood.

Seem like the going discounts to be had are 8-10% off - if you lease there's an add'l $2k rebate currently. If you've been in BMW CCA for a year, throw in another $1k rebate.

If the money isn't the issue, I vote M.

[Payton3485]

Thank you all for the comments and opinions! I'm going shopping on Saturday and with all hopes if the numbers are right, I'll leave with an X5 M order placed. Thanks again everyone!

[onfireX5]

I traded a 2016 50i M Sport with dhp to a 2016 X5M. The M in comfort handles better than the 50i in Sport plus.

0-100 in the 50i with BMS is 10.5 seconds

0-100 in the M with RC is 8.6 seconds.

Hard to compare them. M is the real deal. Good luck !

[elisiX]

I test drove the 50i a number of times when buying my M50d. It's a weapon, but a very comfortable weapon.

The X5M is very different. It's raw but still completely compliant on the road. Go with the M for sure.

[Payton3485]

Thanks everyone. I'm definitely leaning HEAVILY towards the M.

Donington Grey Metallic
Mugello Red Full Merino Leather

[PatrickC23]

Curious where you are located, my dealer has Donnington on Mugello, or did when I went, it had just come in. I would have taken it that day if it was carbon black.

If you're lucky enough to find one on the lot to your liking you can do even better I bet. Also if you lease and want to lower money factor, do the MSDs, provided you lease in a state that allows it.

And one thing to add, the interior of the X5M could be even more impressive than the exterior. Throw in some no cost options like CF trim and 21s I think the M is a no brainer.

[Payton3485]

Originally Posted by PatrickC23

Curious where you are located, my dealer has Donnington on Mugello, or did when I went, it had just come in. I would have taken it that day if it was carbon black.

If you're lucky enough to find one on the lot to your liking you can do even better I bet. Also if you lease and want to lower money factor, do the MSDs, provided you lease in a state that allows it.

And one thing to add, the interior of the X5M could be even more impressive than the exterior. Throw in some no cost options like CF trim and 21s I think the M is a no brainer.

Thank you. I'm in the Atlanta area, PatrickC23. I was debating between carbon fiber trim and aluminum trace trim with this color combo. Oh by the way, I really like carbon black as well. Is your combo carbon black/mugello red?

[PatrickC23]

Originally Posted by Payton3485

Thank you. I'm in the Atlanta area, PatrickC23. I was debating between carbon fiber trim and aluminum trace trim with this color combo. Oh by the way, I really like carbon black as well. Is your combo carbon black/mugello red?

Yes, CB on Mugello. I'll be honest, I am not a carbon fiber fan, but with the Mugello it's beautiful, I saw it in person at the dealer. I had an M5 with aluminum trim and red interior but it just didn't look as nice, def try to see the CF and Mugello combo in person, ElisiX has some interior shots that are amazing.

Donnington would be my top choice if my other car wasn't a similar silver, I'd stick with that as it's an exclusive M color, CB is not.

[Payton3485]

Originally Posted by PatrickC23

Yes, CB on Mugello. I'll be honest, I am not a carbon fiber fan, but with the Mugello it's beautiful, I saw it in person at the dealer. I had an M5 with aluminum trim and red interior but it just didn't look as nice, def try to see the CF and Mugello combo in person, ElisiX has some interior shots that are amazing.

Donnington would be my top choice if my other car wasn't a similar silver, I'd stick with that as it's an exclusive M color, CB is not.

Thank you so much! I will definitely try to see carbon fiber trim in person. I may match it up with the Mugello and Donington. That CB looks sharp with Mugello too! Definitely in play for me. Thanks again!

[zero4]

Carbon fiber is nice but the aluminum trace is quite nice as well especially on Mugello. You have to see the aluminum trace in person. You can't really see it well in pics. Nothing like brushed aluminum. Sorry if I made your decision more difficult.

[Payton3485]

Originally Posted by zero4

Carbon fiber is nice but the aluminum trace is quite nice as well especially on Mugello. You have to see the aluminum trace in person. You can't really see it well in pics. Nothing like brushed aluminum. Sorry if I made your decision more difficult.

Ha ha ha, not at all, zero4! That is still my first choice if it shows the way I think it will. I really appreciate all the info and feedback on this forum. You guys are awesome! Thank you!

[Troy172416]

I have carbon fiber with Mugello and I really love it. Everyone who gets in the truck notices the cf right away and comments on it. I think it is unique with cf. really can't go wrong though.

[Payton3485]

Originally Posted by Troy172416

I have carbon fiber with Mugello and I really love it. Everyone who gets in the truck notices the cf right away and comments on it. I think it is unique with cf. really can't go wrong though.

Looks amazing! Nice combo for sure.

[Payton3485]

Decided to definitely go with the X5 M. Please let me know your thoughts on this build and pricing. Mind you, this is the initial price the dealership is giving me so I think there is still some room for additional discounts.

My X5 M
4.4-liter, 32-valve M TwinPower Turbo V-8 engine
M tuned xDrive intelligent all-wheel drive system
See all standard features

BASE MSRP $98,800

Donington Grey Metallic $0
Mugello Red Full Merino Leather $2,900
Aluminum Trace Trim $0
Driver Assistance Plus $1,700
Executive Package $4,500
21" M Light alloy Double Spoke wheels style 612M with perf. non run-flat tires $0
Destination & Handling: $995
BMW Ultimate Service®
A suite of premium benefits that are included at no cost with all new BMW Vehicles.
Up to 4 Years/50,000 Miles WarrantyIncluded
Up to 4 Years/50,000 Miles
Maintenance Program Included
Up to 4 Years/Unlimited Mileage
Roadside Assistance Included

MSRP as Built $108,895
Quoted Price $102,270
Savings of $6,625

[PatrickC23]

Originally Posted by Payton3485

Decided to definitely go with the X5 M. Please let me know your thoughts on this build and pricing. Mind you, this is the initial price the dealership is giving me so I think there is still some room for additional discounts.

My X5 M
4.4-liter, 32-valve M TwinPower Turbo V-8 engine
M tuned xDrive intelligent all-wheel drive system
See all standard features

BASE MSRP $98,800

Donington Grey Metallic $0
Mugello Red Full Merino Leather $2,900
Aluminum Trace Trim $0
Driver Assistance Plus $1,700
Executive Package $4,500
21" M Light alloy Double Spoke wheels style 612M with perf. non run-flat tires $0
Destination & Handling: $995
BMW Ultimate Service®
A suite of premium benefits that are included at no cost with all new BMW Vehicles.
Up to 4 Years/50,000 Miles WarrantyIncluded
Up to 4 Years/50,000 Miles
Maintenance Program Included
Up to 4 Years/Unlimited Mileage
Roadside Assistance Included

MSRP as Built $108,895
Quoted Price $102,270
Savings of $6,625

Nice build, u def have more room in pricing I think. Is this for a purchase or lease? Does it include the additional $2K lease rebate?

[Payton3485]

Originally Posted by PatrickC23

Nice build, u def have more room in pricing I think. Is this for a purchase or lease? Does it include the additional $2K lease rebate?

PatrickC23, this is for a purchase. I'm hoping to get another 2K off if possible. I also have a $1,000 incentive from my wife's job that will be in addition to the negotiated amount. Are there any current incentives for purchases that you are aware of? Thanks for the input as well.

[PatrickC23]

Originally Posted by Payton3485

PatrickC23, this is for a purchase. I'm hoping to get another 2K off if possible. I also have a $1,000 incentive from my wife's job that will be in addition to the negotiated amount. Are there any current incentives for purchases that you are aware of? Thanks for the input as well.

I don't know if the loyalty rebate is still there this month, but doesn't sound like u are a current BMWFS customer anyhow. Only other thing I know about is BMWCCA for $1k, but you need to have been a member for one consecutive year by delivery.

You would qualify for any other incentives that come out at delivery however.

[Payton3485]

Originally Posted by PatrickC23

I don't know if the loyalty rebate is still there this month, but doesn't sound like u are a current BMWFS customer anyhow. Only other thing I know about is BMWCCA for $1k, but you need to have been a member for one consecutive year by delivery.

You would qualify for any other incentives that come out at delivery however.

Thanks! Those were the only two rebates I was aware of but you are correct, I would not qualify for either with this purchase. Thanks again!

[cmyx6go]

Originally Posted by Payton3485

Thanks everyone. I'm definitely leaning HEAVILY towards the M.

Donington Grey Metallic
Mugello Red Full Merino Leather

Do more than lean heavily, get the M. I have a bunch of posts here about my disappointment with the 2016 50i albeit the X6, After 4 months I traded it in for the M. Order the M and have a blast.